How to Handle a Fake Review of Your Small Business
A framing shop I work with picked up three one star reviews in a single Tuesday evening. All three mentioned rude staff at the counter, which would have been worth taking seriously except that the shop had been shut since lunchtime for a...

A framing shop I work with picked up three one star reviews in a single Tuesday evening. All three mentioned rude staff at the counter, which would have been worth taking seriously except that the shop had been shut since lunchtime for a funeral. The owner spent the next two days writing and deleting replies, and by Thursday her rating had slipped from 4.7 to 4.4 and she had not slept properly.
That is the real cost of a fake review, and it is not the star. It is the forty hours a small business owner spends on something that should take twenty minutes and then a decision. Most advice on this starts with how to report it to the platform, which in my experience is the step least likely to work. The order matters, and the order most people use is backwards.
Telling a fake apart from a harsh but genuine one
Start here, because the two need opposite responses and because owners are terrible at this call about their own business. Nobody wants to believe the review is real.
A genuine angry review almost always contains something only a customer would know: the day, the name of the person they dealt with, the item, the price, the smell of the place. The complaint may be unfair and the facts may be wrong, but it is specific. A fabricated one stays general, because the writer has nothing to draw on. Phrases like poor service, unprofessional and would not recommend with no detail attached are the signature, and so is a reviewer profile with exactly one review on it.
The other tell is timing. Real reviews arrive scattered. Four one star reviews between 9pm and 11pm on a weeknight is a pattern, and patterns in reviews are worth reading properly, which we go into in our piece on spotting patterns in customer reviews and complaints.
Check your own records before you decide. Search the reviewer name in your booking system, your till, your email. In the framing shop case it took four minutes to confirm no transaction matched, and that evidence changed everything about how the reply was written.
The first forty eight hours, in order
- Screenshot everything, including the reviewer profile and the timestamp. Profiles get deleted and you will want the record if this becomes a pattern or a legal matter.
- Check your records for any matching transaction. Write down what you searched and what you found, in one line, dated.
- Post a short public reply within about 24 hours. Not a defence. A factual, calm note that invites contact.
- Report it to the platform, with the specific policy it breaks rather than a general complaint that it is untrue.
- Ask three recent happy customers for a review, in person or by message, not as a campaign. Volume is the only lever that reliably moves your rating.
Step three before step four is the part people argue with me about, so let me take the argument head on.
Reporting it first is the advice I would skip
Every guide tells you to flag the review and wait. I have watched this play out across maybe thirty small businesses in the last few years and my rough count is that under a third of flagged reviews come down, and the ones that do take between four days and three weeks. Those odds are not nothing. They are also not a plan.
Meanwhile, the review is sitting there being read. The people whose opinion actually matters are not the platform's moderation team, they are the customers scrolling your profile tomorrow afternoon. Those people are far more forgiving than owners expect, and research on review behaviour has said for years that a visible owner reply changes how a negative review lands. What they are judging is not the accusation. It is how you carry yourself when accused.
So reply first, flag second, and treat the flag as a lottery ticket rather than a solution. If it comes down, good. If it does not, your reply is doing the work either way.
One qualification. If the review contains a threat, a demand for money, or someone else's personal information, report it immediately and do not reply at all. That is extortion or a privacy breach rather than a review, and the platforms do act faster on those categories.
What the reply should actually say
Three sentences. Any longer and you look rattled.
Name the gap in the record without calling the person a liar. Something close to this: "Thank you for the feedback. We have checked our records for this date and cannot find an order or a visit that matches, so we may have the wrong business or the wrong details. If you did visit us, please call the shop on the number below and ask for Tanvir, because I would like to understand what happened."
That does four things at once. It stays courteous for the benefit of every future reader. It plants the doubt without an accusation. It offers a route off the public page. And it quietly signals that you keep records, which deters the next one. The tone is the same one we recommend for genuine complaints in replying to a one star Google review without making it worse, because future customers cannot tell which kind they are reading.
What not to write: anything with the word defamation in it, anything that names a competitor, any sentence longer than about twenty words, and any explanation of your side of an event you have no evidence happened. I have seen a shop lose far more trade from a furious 200 word reply than from the fake review above it.
How much a single fake review actually costs you
Less than it feels like, and the arithmetic is worth doing because it calms people down.
The framing shop had 41 reviews averaging 4.7, which is about 193 stars in total. Three one star reviews took her to 44 reviews and 196 stars, an average of 4.45, which displays as 4.5 on most profiles. To get back above 4.65 she needed roughly eight new five star reviews. She asked eleven customers over three weeks and got nine, two of which were the best written reviews on her profile.
The lesson I take from that is unglamorous: a business with 40 reviews is fragile and a business with 200 is close to immune. If one bad actor can move your public rating by a quarter of a star, the real problem is not the bad actor. It is that you have been shy about asking, and the fix for that is covered in asking customers for reviews without sounding pushy.
I will admit the limits of my own view here. I see the cases where owners reach out for help, which skews toward the ones that resolved badly or dragged on. There are probably plenty of fake reviews that got removed in two days and nobody ever mentioned them to me.
FAQ
Can I get a fake review removed from Google?
Sometimes. Flag it against a specific policy, usually the one about content from someone with no genuine experience of the business, and give the dates you checked in your records. Expect it to take days rather than hours, and expect most flags to fail.
Should I reply to a review I am certain is fake?
Yes, once, briefly, and for the audience rather than the reviewer. A short factual reply is what future customers read. Arguing in a thread is what they remember.
What if a competitor is clearly behind it?
Keep the screenshots and the dates and say nothing publicly. A pattern across several weeks is far more persuasive to a platform, and to a solicitor if it ever goes that far, than one review and a suspicion.
Do fake positive reviews hurt me?
They do, more than owners think. They attract the wrong customers, who then write genuine disappointed reviews, and that cycle is much harder to recover from than one unfair star.
More in Feedback and Reviews
Feedback and Reviews
How to Get Feedback From Frontline Staff Each Week
Your reviews say the wait at the counter is too long. Your till data says service times are fine.
Feedback and Reviews
How to Spot Patterns in Customer Reviews and Complaints
You read every new review as it comes in, reply to the angry ones, feel good about the kind ones, and still have no idea what...
Feedback and Reviews
How to Handle Conflicting Customer Feedback in a Small Shop
One customer says your coffee is too strong. The next says it is too weak.