How to Time Reorder Reminders So Customers Buy Again
A customer buys a 30 day bag of dog food from you in March. In April she buys the next one from a supermarket, because she ran out on a Sunday and you were not in her head. She did not leave because of price or service.

A customer buys a 30 day bag of dog food from you in March. In April she buys the next one from a supermarket, because she ran out on a Sunday and you were not in her head. She did not leave because of price or service. She left because nothing reminded her you existed at the moment she needed you. Most small shops never see this happen. The order just stops appearing.
The obvious fix is a reorder reminder, and plenty of shops already send one. The problem I keep seeing in the complaints and replies that land in shared inboxes is timing. Reminders arrive a week after the customer already restocked elsewhere, or two weeks early so they feel like nagging, or on a fixed day that has nothing to do with how that household actually uses the product. A reminder that lands at the wrong moment reads as spam. Sent at the right one, it gets thanked.
Why a fixed schedule misses most customers
The default in most email tools is a single delay after purchase. Thirty days for a 30 day product. It sounds sensible, and it is wrong for roughly half your buyers.
Product labels describe ideal use, not real use. A 30 day supply of vitamins lasts 30 days if the customer takes one every day without fail. Most people miss a few, so the tub lasts 36 or 40. A 2 kilo bag of coffee beans that a single person drinks lasts far longer than the same bag in a house with two heavy drinkers. Dog food depends on the dog. One reminder date for all of them guarantees some customers hear from you when the shelf is still half full, and others after they have run dry.
I went through about 140 replies to reorder emails for a small tea retailer last year. The single most common negative reply, at around 31 of them, was some version of "I still have plenty, stop emailing me." The second most common was "I already bought it somewhere else, you should have told me sooner." Same email, same delay, opposite complaints. That is the signature of a schedule that ignores the customer.
Work out each customer's real interval
You do not need software for this. A spreadsheet export of orders is enough. For any customer with at least two purchases of the same item, the gap between orders tells you how fast they use it.
Take the dates of their last two or three orders of that product and find the average gap in days. If someone bought tea on 4 January, 15 February and 27 March, their gaps are 42 and 40 days, so their interval is about 41. Send the reminder around 7 days before that, at day 34 after the last order. That leaves time for delivery and avoids the empty shelf moment.
For first time buyers you have no history, so use the median gap for that product across all repeat buyers. In the tea shop's data, the label said 30 days and the median real gap was 38. Sending at day 31 instead of day 23 cut the "I still have plenty" replies by more than half in the first two months. That is a small sample from one shop, so I would not promise the same result, but the direction has held everywhere I have seen it tried.
Update the interval as new orders come in. Someone who adopts a second dog or starts working from home will speed up, and the reminder should follow.
The case against discount codes in reminders
Most reorder templates include a 10 percent code. The thinking is that a nudge with an incentive converts better, and it does in the short term. I think it is a mistake for products people would buy anyway.
A customer who was going to reorder at full price now waits for the code every cycle. You have trained them to expect it, and the reminder becomes a coupon delivery service. Worse, if you ever drop the code, some customers read it as a price rise and complain. I have seen that exact complaint come in three separate times from shops that tried to wean buyers off a permanent reminder discount.
What works better is convenience. A one click reorder link that loads their last basket, their usual size already selected, and a delivery estimate. If you want to reward loyalty, do it occasionally and without warning, which feels like a gift rather than a price. The loyalty program ideas on this site cover ways to do that without eroding margin.
What the reminder should actually say
Short. The customer should understand it in the preview line on their phone. Here is the structure that has drawn the fewest complaints in the replies I have read.
- Subject line names the product and the timing. "Your Assam leaf is probably running low" beats "We miss you" or "Time to restock."
- First line admits it is an estimate. "Based on your last few orders, you might be getting near the end." This one phrase reduces annoyed replies, because it shows you are guessing from their habits rather than pushing a calendar.
- One button to reorder the same basket. No product grid, no new arrivals.
- A snooze option. A link that says "Remind me in two weeks instead." It is the single most valuable line in the email. It turns "stop emailing me" into useful data about their real interval.
- A plain reply address. Let people answer. Some will tell you they switched products, moved house or had a problem with the last order, which is feedback you would otherwise never hear.
That last point matters to me more than the conversion rate. A reminder is one of the few emails a regular customer is likely to reply to, and the replies are honest in a way surveys rarely are.
Measuring whether it worked
Do not judge reminders by open rate. Judge them by whether the customer's next order came from you, and how close to their interval it arrived. Track two numbers for each product: the share of repeat buyers who reordered within 10 days of their expected date, and the share who went quiet for more than double their interval. If you already calculate customer retention rate, add these as a monthly line beside it.
Customers who pass double their interval without ordering are the ones to treat differently. A second reorder reminder rarely helps. They need a personal note asking whether something went wrong, and the approach in winning back a customer who stopped buying fits that moment better than another automated message.
This week, export your last six months of orders, pick your single most repurchased product, and find the median gap between orders. If it differs from your current reminder delay by more than five days, change the delay. That one adjustment is often enough to see the difference in replies within a month.
FAQ
When should I send a reorder reminder email?
About 5 to 7 days before the customer would normally run out, based on the gap between their previous orders. For first time buyers, use the median reorder gap for that product across all customers.
How many reorder reminders should I send?
One, with a snooze link. A second reminder a week later can work for consumables, but a third almost always produces unsubscribes and complaints rather than orders.
Do reorder reminders work for small shops?
Yes, often better than for big retailers, because a small shop can write in a personal voice and actually read the replies. Even a manual list of 50 regulars, emailed by hand, can lift repeat orders.
Should reorder reminders include a discount?
Usually not for products people buy regularly. Discounts train customers to wait for the code. A one click reorder link and an honest estimate tend to work better over a year.
More in Loyalty and Retention
Loyalty and Retention
How to Keep Seasonal Customers Buying in the Quiet Months
A garden centre near me takes roughly 58 percent of its annual revenue between the middle of March and the end of May.
Loyalty and Retention
Customer Birthday Offers That Actually Bring People Back
You collected birthdays at signup, you send a "Happy birthday, here is 10 percent off" email every month, and almost nobody...
Loyalty and Retention
How to Write a Thank You Note to Repeat Customers
Your regulars keep coming back, and you would like to tell them you notice, but every "thank you for your loyalty" message you...